RPG Corner: Changing Difficulty

Say your player’s characters keep dying? Do you make the encounters easier? Do you relocate the PC’s? Do you keep running them through the gauntlet until a set of characters rises to the top?

In the most recent (at the time of writing) episode of Nevre: Yeodiax (which is set in a future of the setting for Fractured Mountains) I had to decide whether to send the group back to the wilderness, where they keep dying, or keep them in the city, where they have a chance to level up some before heading back out?

My solution was to keep them in the city and send them on a short filler quest to deliver a chest that turned out to be [spoilers]. (If you wish to watch the episode it’s on my YouTube channel linked at the end of this post.)

My solution was to send them somewhere I knew they were more likely to survive. I also toned down the encounters a little, but forgot to take into account that we had an extra player for the session. Survival rates increase greatly with just one more character.

There are many places and times that just pulling the characters out of the fire isn’t an option that allows the players to keep their buy-in. I had the only survivor captured and dragged to the goblin caves near the city, but that’s not always an option.

If I didn’t have somewhere close by to send the characters I probably would have started to tone down the encounters a little. I had already started doing this at the beginning of the campaign. I removed the ability for kobolds to use pack tactics because I had instituted flanking. Getting the characters thinking about optimal placement to both activate flanking and avoid being flanked goes out the window when enemies don’t have to position for advantage.

An easy way to tone down encounters is to have the enemies use bad tactics. Instead of flanking at the start of the battle they just spread out and try to take on characters one to one. The players are then free to disengage and position for advantage if they wish. The only exception to this is that the caster should not be targeted and the monsters that would target them should go after the fighter/barbarian/monk/etc.

So, when it comes to combat, to make it easier for your players either get them to move somewhere that has less difficult encounters or use less optimal tactics against them. There’s also the chance that your players aren’t tactically minded and using less optimal tactics doesn’t change anything. In that case I recommend lowering the CR of future encounters, little by little until you reach a sweet spot. Finding the CR sweet spot is difficult and CR is more of a guideline than a ruler.

Likewise, you can increase the combat difficulty, if the characters are breezing through things that you want to slow them down, by doing the opposite. Start using better tactics. If that doesn’t work then slightly increase the CR.

But what about if they keep failing your skill-based challenges? This is maybe an easier question. There are recommended difficulties for skills in the 5e DMG. Do not scale these up based on level unless someone is proficient in that skill, and then only by one or two. It may seem like the characters are failing a lot, but remember that their ideas on how to handle the situation should give modifiers to the roll.

For example, there’s three doors in front of the characters. Two lead to traps and one leads forward. There is a riddle in front of them which, when solved, tells them which door is the correct one. If the group’s survivalist wants to make the check easier by finding which door has the most air flow coming from beneath it, let him roll and if he succeeds give them a +2 modifier for solving the riddle (or a hint if you don’t want them to roll to solve the riddle).

[My Books], [My Discord], [My Facebook Page], [My Ko-Fi], [My Patreon], [My Twitter], [My YouTube]

RPG Corner: Joke Magic Items

Happy April Fools! Have I got some great magic items for you! They never break! *bangs item against table* It broke…

These are all auto-attune cursed items built for D&D 5e. When you attempt to identify these items they become attuned to you!

First up on the list, Quarterstaff of Smells!
When attuned to this quarterstaff you smell like cow manure no matter how hard you scrub. Once the attunement is broken the smell dissipates in 1d4 days. You feel compelled to never remove the quarterstaff from your person while attuned.

Now, Torch of Neverlight!
When attuned to this torch you see bright light as dim light and dim light as…dim light. Both before and after attuning the torch cannot be lit by any means short of being on the plane of fire. You feel compelled to never remove the torch from your person while attuned.

Next, Mask of Forget
When attuned to this mask you feel compelled to wear it, DC 15 Wisdom save to resist every dawn. When you don the mask you forget who you are, but you still retain your ability scores and proficiencies. DC 15 Wisdom save to remove the mask, also at dawn. You feel compelled to never remove the mask from your person while attuned.

Another! *breaks coffee mug on floor* Amulet of Never Drunk
When attuned to this amulet you cannot get drunk, no matter how hard you try! You can still get alcohol poisoning, so watch out! You feel compelled to never remove the amulet from your person while attuned. (I recommend giving this to the party’s drunken dwarf.)

Finally, Deaf’s Embrace
When attuned to this cloak you feel compelled to wear it and call yourself Deaf Himself. While wearing the cloak you are deafened. You feel compelled to never remove the cloak from your person while attuned.

[My Books], [My Discord], [My Facebook Page], [My Ko-Fi], [My Patreon], [My Twitter], [My YouTube]

RPG Corner, Homebrew – D&D 5e: The Underdark

RPG Corner

I’ve made a few creatures to be used in the Under Dark for South Reaches. These are creatures that I created for The Fractured Mountains originally. The ones here are the Ankyloslime and the Strange Salamander. These have not been playtested so the listed CR may be incorrect. The links lead to their D&D Beyond page. Continue reading

RPG Corner, Homebrew: D&D 5e – Teblats

[RPG Corner is a monthly post where I talk about something related to Role-Playing Games.]

Teblats appear in a part of Rebuilding Brangmar, and they will probably show up again.

Teblats can take the form of any tiny creature. The creature itself isn’t the teblat, instead the teblat is a parasite that gives the animal protection but also causes the animal to be more aggressive and appear to have a blue aura. This aura grows stronger when they have more temporary hit points and is very dim when they have none.

Sentient creatures cannot be affected by a teblat infestation. Continue reading

RPG Corner, Homebrew – D&D 5e: Face-Mask

[RPG Corner is a monthly post where I talk about something related to Role-Playing Games.]

I created a creature based off of a creature in the series Pathfinder by Orson Scott Card called a facemask. Here is a link to the Wikipedia page for the book series: link. I also released the Face-Mask as a homebrew creature on DnD Beyond, the creature’s name in at the start of the stat block is a link.

Face-Masks look and feel like a mass of wet, rotting refuse, but do not be fooled! If they touch a creature they turn that creature into either a living zombie or a freak of nature. Continue reading

RPG Corner, Homebrew – D&D 5e: Quarterlings

[RPG Corner is a monthly post where I talk about something related to Role-Playing Games.]

Quarterlings (aka Half-Dwarves) are a race that was created by my friend Michael for a D&D game that is going up on my YouTube channel Sword or Sorcery. He created this race in case someone wanted to play the race he and his mother created for a world they are working on together. With his permission I present you with the Quarterling stat block. Continue reading